|
Steve Garfield on pop culture and technology.
If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed.
Learn more about Steve Garfield. Watch my videos. Want more frequent updates follow me on Twitter. Thanks for visiting! Saturday, December 30, 2006
John Edwards Meets the Bloggers
![]() John Edwards Meets the Bloggers by stevegarfield, uploaded from flickr. Going into this meet the bloggers event I was wondering how I'd get a chance to talk to John Edwards about video blogging when he was only scheduled for 15 minutes with us and there were 20 bloggers in the curtained off area. I posted links to all the videos over on John Edwards blog.
Comments:
I don't think that he is talking with the bloggers to talk about blogging though. He doesn't talk about making news to the MSM. It is all about his grassroots campaign and he wants to be asked the questions that aren't being asked by MSM to give bloggers the chance to break a story. I think that is what the Scobles and Chuck were there for. To talk about blogging.
Thanks Jeff. Good point.
Like I said in the post, "...it doesn't have to be about blogging, but at least ask something that doesn't get you a standard stump speech reply." The bloggers did not ask anything different from MSM in this meeting. I know it's hard to come up with something new and different, but what happened was just a question and answer session. It didn't turn into a conversation. The bloggers ended up acting just like reporters. I would not have done that.
I would have thought there would be discussion about how JRE intends to use other web 2.0 based technology in innovative ways in order to reach a larger audience, in a more personal and real-time way. For example - does he have any plans to use Second Life to hold real-time, on-line briefings or town halls. Has he looked at using mashups? That sort of thing....
You are right about the unsatisfying parts of the meet & greet. We didn't get to konw John Edwards. If I were to get to know Edwards - as a person - I would either work for him or not.
I got to know Ned Lamont - as a person - merely by listening to him repeatedly in informal settings. I simply liked the guy, felt he was honest, and knew he could do the job. Therefore, I volunteered for him ... by helping to introduce people to the campaign, or helping to organize some events, or phonebanking, or yelling at people in the street (perhaps that part was ill-advised), or whatever. I don't yet seem to like John Edwards, but I am edging towards it. It is of course true that he is a better option that H. Clinton or Barak Obama. But I will have to see him in person more. Edwards is very much "on" and the MSM questions in the "blogger room" didn't break that down. Something to work on. Even without good lighting or electrical outlets, it was great meeting you, Steve.
Steve and I talked about this a little bit at the event in New Hampshire and I want to related some of what I said there.
15 minutes: Yeah, I would like to get bloggers to have more time with Sen. Edwards. It is hard to get time, and I hope we can get more, use it more effectively, and eventually get longer periods of time with Sen. Edwards. One question per blogger: That's probably my fault. I helped organize it, but all from a fairly unofficial role with no guidelines. I sat back and let things happen, which is generally how I like to approach things, but I probably should have set better ground rules ahead of time. Let's talk about blogging: I think Dean from BlueHampshire asked a good question about the role of new media. I would have liked to seen more of that, as well as more give and take. We shouldn't be there just to ask Sen. Edwards what he thinks, but we should give our own thoughts about what makes sense. Beyond that, I think the important part is not to talk about blogging, but to talk about all those things that the traditional media is missing. To me, the key part of Sen. Edwards' message is about getting people active in making our country a better place, yet the press is busy with their current hot narratives like Iraq and Obama and as such aren't really hearing or reporting on Edwards message. A well lit area: Yeah. That sucked. We were supposed to have a good well lit area, but there were logistical difficulties that precluded that. Hopefully we will get a better venue next time. Turning Sen. Edwards into a true video blogger. I would have loved to video taped you handing him your camera, giving him your great five second, here's how you start videoblogging, and seeing what he can do. Site comment to Carol. I'm on Second Life. I tried to get the Lamont campaign to do something there. It didn't happen. Maybe we can get the Edwards campaign to do something there, or perhaps we do a citizen launch ourselves. Check out this diary over on the Edwards site (as well as my comment there). If you're interested, comment there, add me as a friend at SLProfiles, etc.
Hey, Mike Caulfield from Blue Hampshire here. I asked the question about new media.
The answer he gave was not really to the question I asked. I was actually asking him not if he planned to use it, but what he thught its role was. I know he's using it, but why? What is it we do that the MSM doesn't? I agree that we shouldn't be asking questions that the MSM is going to ask 300 times. I am unsure of what we should be doing. I think in one respect, regardless of technology, we are the activist media, and there's a role there. And I think not being under professional constraints, we can be a little more agile, and change the story being told (e.g. with Edwards the story is not Iraq or Poverty, but the campaign as movement idea he is pushing...we can push that analysis to the MSM, where they seem to be focussed on covering the last campaign...I would not be surprised if the Edwards as Dean 2.0 question we are posing on the blogs makes it to the weeklies very soon...that's part of our true power...to bust apart inappropriate frames and replace them with new ones...
John Edwards knows a lot about poverty, after all, he's helped throw a lot of people into it with:
- his co-sponsorship of H-1b visas, - his support for illegal aliens, - his vote for MFN-China but what about stuff like iraq war and the patriot act? well, he voted for them too About the only think you can say for Edwards is, he spent so much time running for president that he didnt have time to do more damage as senator
A concern I have is that some bloggers, Drew Baron and Chuck Olsen, for example, were paid by the Edwards campaign to post video on line about the candidate. I was predisposed toward Edwards until I read about that in The Washington Post. IMHO, it makes him seem like just another prepackaged candidate, and even more distressing, it makes me question the objectivity of videobloggers I've really come to trust.
Post a Comment
I tried to leave a similar message on your Vlog Soup site. Perhaps it is more appropriate here. Links to this post:![]() This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License. If you use my content, please link to the permalink of the blog post. If possible, list the credit as "Steve Garfield / SteveGarfield.com", and link to stevegarfield.com Please link to me. Here's the code to copy and paste: <a href="http://offonatangent.blogspot.com/" title="Off On A Tangent">Off On A Tangent</a>.
We have no problem with parents deciding
that some of the content on this site is inappropriate for their children. |
Get updates with RSS stevegarfield.com contact me Disclosure and About Mobile Version Boston Media Makers Blog Panasonic Test Center - Living in HD More About Me ![]() Watch My Videos
I'm Speaking at BlogWorld & New Media Expo 2009
Qik Videos
Lijit Search Watch my Lifestream at Tumblr A combined feed of all my stuff Backtype - My comments *New* Swurl Timeline Swurl Calendar Vlog Soup - Video Tour Me on techPresident Carol and Steve Show 05 , 06 , 07 , 08 My VOX blog My Rocketboom reports New Mediacracy Podcast Learn About Videoblogging Personal Cellphone Webcast Page
2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008
more cowbell Get a t-shirt! Put an ad like this on your site Search this blog: [ Sponsored Links ] 1&1 Hosting Dreamhost Hosting Constant Contact® CafePress CustomFlix All Things Natural amazon.com [ My Other Sites ] Steve Garfield's Video Blog Steve Garfield's Jivjiv Store Steve Garfield's CafePress Store Boston Photobloggers my photo blog me on vimeo my button museum my list tivo-b0rking clown store my eBay me as superman vspan: test video blog video podcast: another test vlog School of Rock Super Fan Site Weblog Boston Beer Mob [ I Contribute To ] ![]() Rocketboom participate.net vimeo Universal Hub We Are The Media Fast Food Fever joshua.com My Mom's Blog votejohntobin.com [ My Feeds ] RSS 2.0 Feed
[ Archives ]
Boston Events Tickets [ Videoblogs ] Vlog Universe Vlog Map [ TV ] Lost Remote reality blurred TV Snob TV Barn TV Picks msx.tv TWOP realitytvworld [ Humor ] Tim McIntire - Poor control. Bill Simmons - Sports Guy. Channel 101 - Comedy TV. Chumworth - Now a Blog! Joe Lavin - New on Tuesday. halfbakery - Serving suggestion. Late Night - Leno and Letterman. Borowitz Report - Not real. White House - Even not realer.
"Hi Creep! This is a great idea. I'll check in to this site from time to time. You guys are always thinking up new stuff. Us "thinkers" need to stick together!" Karlson "Steve, You rock. Thanks for the link. And "Am I Geek Or Not" is beyond great." -John Aboud Co-Editor, Modern Humorist
Powered by Blogger |
|