Steve Garfield on pop culture, Food, and technology.


Thursday, January 14, 2010
Haiti Photo: Home is all rubble now. How it spread from a cellphone, to twitpic, to twitter, to Getty, AFP and more.

Metro Front Page: Hsiti rocked by massive quake

I saw this image from Haiti in a copy of yesterday's Metro newspaper. It's the newpaper that you pick up on the subway.

The caption read, "A Twitter image purportedly shows Haitians standing amid rubble yesterday in Port-au-Prince after the earthquake."

There was no credit given to the photographer.

That annoys me.

Twitter image
Twitter does not host images, so the image was found VIA twitter, but was actually posted elsewhere. It's not really a twitter image. Is it?

Username
Where was the twitter username?

That's like TV stations crediting videos that they take off of YouTube as "YouTube video." There is a user name associated with the video. Credit them!

Image Credit
So back to this photo. The photo had an image credit of AFP/Getty Images, so I started a search and found this.


GETTY Images
This image obtained from Twitter purportedly shows Haitians standing amid rubble on January 12, 2010 in Port-au-Prince after a huge quake measuring 7.0 rocked the impoverished Caribbean nation of Haiti, toppling buildings and causing widespread damage and panic, officials and AFP witnesses said. A tsunami alert was immediately issued for the Caribbean region after the earthquake struck at 2153 GMT. AFP PHOTO / TWITTER == RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE / NO SALES == (Photo credit should read -/AFP/Getty Images)

Then I found this on AFP:


AFP
HAITI, Port-au-Prince : ------ EDITORS NOTE ----- ADDING NAME OF PHOTOGRAPHER -----

This image obtained from Twitter purportedly shows Haitians standing amid rubble on January 12, 2010 in Port-au-Prince after a huge quake measuring 7.0 rocked the impoverished Caribbean nation of Haiti, toppling buildings and causing widespread damage and panic, officials and AFP witnesses said. A tsunami alert was immediately issued for the Caribbean region after the earthquake struck at 2153 GMT. AFP PHOTO / CAREL PEDRE == RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE / NO SALES ==

Credit
AFP
Source
AFP
Creation date
2010-01-13 00:36 +00:00
Photographer
CAREL PEDRE
They determined the photographer's name and added it to the AFP site, but that doesn't help for all the places it went uncredited.

Next is the local TV station which has a credit for the photographer.



WCVB
Credit: AP Photo / Carel Pedre

CT Post also credits the photographer.



CTPOST
This photo provided by Carel Pedre shows people running past rubble of a damaged building in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, Tuesday, Jan. 12, 2010. The largest earthquake ever recorded in the area shook Haiti on Tuesday, collapsing a hospital where people screamed for help. Photo: Carel Pedre / AP

Mashable reports on the source of the image. Twitter posts by Marvin Addy of cellphone photos taken by Carel Pedre.

Nice job Mashable.


Mashable - Haiti Earthquake: Twitter Pictures Sweep Across the Web [PHOTOS]:
An outpouring of well wishes and support for the Haitian people has swept the web in the wake of a devastating 7.0 earthquake in Haiti. And just like during the Eureka earthquake, tweets have quickly spread moving and gut-wrenching TwitPics of the disaster.

Photos taken by journalist @CarelPedre on his mobile phone are providing a glimpse into the devastation that has slammed the Caribbean nation. Another Twitter user, @MarvinAdy, shared those pictures through TwitPic, resulting in tens of thousands of views and countless retweets.

Here's Carel Pedre's twitter page and websites...


Carel Pedre on Twitter
Carel Pedre Official Site
Carel Pedre on Flickr

Here's Marvin Ady's posting on TwitPic.


@MarvinAdy

It's interesting to read the comments and see all the news outlets asking for photos.


Marvin Ady TwitPic Comments

This is the state of news.

Real time direct reports from people at the scene using social media tools like twitter, twitpic, flickr and more.

Update:

TF1 News - Carel Pedre, the eyes of Haiti: [ Transated from French ]
Soon after the quake, it is clear the streets, going door to door to check how will his friends and collect the testimonies of those who have lost everything. With his mobile phone, it takes pictures that he sends her Twitter service via TwitPic. CNN publishes on its website. "Honestly, these pictures are not representative of the extent of damage," says Carel Pedre, live on the big American chain. Among the first eyewitness of the catastrophe, his photos are taken by the agencies and published in U.S. newspapers. One of them is including a prestigious Washington Post.








Comments:
I watched that same image emerge several different locations as well..and so many didn't have the credits as you've pointed out. I wondered too who took this..thank you for knowing how to trace it back. I'm now following those you've cited. Grateful for your discerning thought that knew to give Carel Pedre and Marvin Ady appropriate credit.

 
I also want to thank you for tracking this down. There was just something particularly haunting about that image. I first saw it as a Twitpic, posted it on the Boston Haitian Reporter site. I've changed the credit there to Pedre.

 
As a 4th year photography undergraduate student about to graduate, the state of the news offends me. Twitter pictures as headlines??? I think we should allow the twitter-ers to write the news as well. Then no one will have a job! Ha!

 
Very interesting post. News gathering is changing in modern times, which has its pros and its cons. This post highlighted this as clearly as I have seen anywhere. Thanks for the thought provoking post.

 
Interesting post and great research. I had the same thing happen to me recently - on a local level, but still it was a big let down to see my work spread around without proper credit.

 
So Getty Images grabs pictures off of TwitPic and sells licenses to them on their website without knowing who the photographer is? Sounds kinda shady to me.

 
Oh that photo is very sad!! But the way, thanks for the information of how spread that photo on diferent places!!

 
He looked happy, good luck. I watched that same image emerge several different locations as well. Thanks. Viagra you Best ED Solution.

 
Oh that photo is very sad!! But the way, thanks for the information of how spread that photo on diferent places

 
I suggest this site to my friends so it could be useful & informative for them also. Great effort.

 
Hello .. firstly I would like to send greetings to all readers. After this, I recognize the content so interesting about this article. For me personally I liked all the information. I would like to know of cases like this more often. In my personal experience I might mention a book called Generic Viagra in this book that I mentioned have very interesting topics, and also you have much to do with the main theme of this article.

 
To start with I would like to congratulate the cradores of this blog, mainly because when I read it I enjoyed it very much. A few years ago I attended a conference called guanacaste costa rica real estate, at that conference had many interesting topics. Perhaps readers may find no relationship between the blog and this conference, but if someday can attend, would realize that there is much to do with this blog.

 
For men who want bigger, harder, longer-lasting erections, there's now VigRX Plus™, a fresh twist on the already popular VigRX™, but designed to further enhance men's sexual functioning with the addition of three exciting new ingredients: Damiana, Tribulus, and Bioperin. Doctor endorsed and rated #1 for results by clients of penis enlargement consumers. rated two penis pills is vimax. if you find about male enhancement this products is the best and proven to work, there products have money-back guarantee in effectiveness and result.

 

Post a Comment



Links to this post:









Follow me on G+


Follow me on twitter


Tweet to @SteveGarfield


Get Seen Facebook Page



Get the blog sent to your inbox.
Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


stevegarfield.com
contact me
Disclosure and About


Author: Get Seen, Online Video Secrets / Founder: Boston Media Makers / Investor / Host: SteveGarfield.tv
Boston Media Makers Blog

View Steve Garfield's profile on LinkedIn

www.flickr.com




Tumblr
A combined feed of all my stuff

My Rocketboom reports
Learn About Videoblogging

The Carol and Steve Show
2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008

more cowbell
Get a t-shirt!

Put an ad like this on your site

[ Sponsored Links ]
1&1 Hosting
Dreamhost Hosting
Constant Contact®
CafePress
CustomFlix

All Things Natural

amazon.com



[ My Other Sites ]
Steve Garfield's Video Blog
Steve Garfield's CafePress Store

Boston Photobloggers
my photo blog

me on vimeo
my button museum
my list
tivo-b0rking
clown store
my eBay
me as superman
vspan: test video blog
video podcast: another test vlog
School of Rock Super Fan Site Weblog
Boston Beer Mob

[ I Contribute To ]

Rocketboom
participate.net
vimeo
Universal Hub
We Are The Media

Fast Food Fever
joshua.com
My Mom's Blog
votejohntobin.com


[ My Feeds ]
RSS 2.0 Feed

Add to My Yahoo!

Subscribe with Bloglines

[ Archives ]


  • Boston Events Tickets

    [ Videoblogs ]

    Vlog Universe
    Vlog Map


    [ TV ]
    Lost Remote
    reality blurred
    TV Snob
    TV Barn
    TWOP
    realitytvworld

    [ Humor ]
    Tim McIntire - Poor control.
    Bill Simmons - Sports Guy.
    Channel 101 - Comedy TV.
    Chumworth - Now a Blog!
    Joe Lavin - New on Tuesday.
    halfbakery - Serving suggestion.
    Late Night - Leno and Letterman.
    Borowitz Report - Not real.
    White House - Even not realer.


    Garfield Standup Template Check out my button collection where I have Pop Culture: The Beatles, The Greatful Dead, Matchbox, Rocky Horror, Question Authority, Cancer Cures Smoking, Make Love Not War, Draft Beer Not Students, Stifle Yourself, Thanks For Not Smoking, Stop Nuclear Power, I Can't Believe I Ate The Whole Thing...; Politics: Kenedy, Nixon, Agnew, McGovern, Mondale, Ford, Anderson, Bunker, Dewey, Stevenson, RB Hayes, Benjamin Harrison, Coolidge and Dawes, Hoover, Garfield, IKE...; New Wave: The Clash, pil, XTC, Ian Drury, The Specials, The Tubes, Iggy Pop, Sex Pistols, Buzzcocks, Joe Jackson, Pretenders, Stiff Records, Gang of Four, the beat, adam and the antz, bad manners, 2 TONE, Blondie, Psychedelic Furs, XTC, B-52's, Lene Lovich, The Knack, The Jam, The Police, Rude Boys, The Specials, slits, The Who, pil, Elvis Costello UK Subs, Sid Vicious, Rachel Sweet, V, Magazine, Nick Lowe, Blondie, Elvis Costello, Talking Heads, David Byrne, Wire, Bryan Ferry, UBU Dance Party, Kleenex, The Clash, XTC...
    "Hi Creep!
    This is a great idea. I'll check in to this site from time to time.
    You guys are always thinking up new stuff. Us "thinkers" need to stick together!"
    Karlson

    "Steve,
    You rock. Thanks for the link.
    And "Am I Geek Or Not" is beyond great."
    -John Aboud Co-Editor, Modern Humorist

    I'm a Fray Subscriber


    Powered by Blogger Pro™
    Powered by Blogger